• Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Login
Friday, November 13, 2026
The Standard
  • News
    • Domestic
    • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Religion
  • Arts & Culture
  • Crossroads
  • About
    • Introducing The Standard
No Result
View All Result
The Standard
  • News
    • Domestic
    • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Religion
  • Arts & Culture
  • Crossroads
  • About
    • Introducing The Standard
No Result
View All Result
The Standard
No Result
View All Result

A Christian Renewal of Feminine and Masculine Ideals for Today’s Society

Mike OrtizbyMike Ortiz
February 28, 2024
in Religion
Reading Time: 8 mins read
0
A Christian Renewal of Feminine and Masculine Ideals for Today’s Society

Photo taken by Lottie King

A prominent feature of modernity, as manifested after the sexual revolution of the 1960s and 70s, is the decline of distinctively masculine and feminine ideals. By “ideals” I do not mean to evoke the more common term of “gender roles,” or at least I think that “ideals” should not be reduced to a mere prescription of roles.

Instead, what I mean is this: a healthy understanding of the differences between men and women, and how those differences, when accompanied by virtue, are strengths rather than weaknesses; i.e., a complementary vision of the sexes under which both “roles” are equally valuable and indispensable, both for the sustenance of society and individual flourishing.

Increasingly, men and women lack a positive understanding of their identities as such, and—perhaps more importantly—of how best to relate with one another. In spite of these trends, Alexandra and Dr. Mike Foley, hosts of the Drinking With the Saints podcast, still have hope for the future of masculine and feminine ideals (as I have defined the term).

As with all problems, it is best to start by addressing the root causes.

Increasingly, men and women lack a positive understanding of their identities as such, and—perhaps more importantly—of how best to relate with one another.

Dr. Michael and Alexandra Foley https://cicdc.org/speakers/michael-p-foley/

“It’s a really hard time to be a woman,” asserts Mrs. Foley, adding that “it’s also a really hard time to be a man.” But it has become exceptionally hard to “embrace the specialness of being a woman.” Agreeing, Dr. Foley finds the cause of this in “a lack of respect for human nature,” the belief “that there is a nature to maleness and femaleness.” Modernity seems to reject this.

The problem, says Mrs. Foley, is that without the distinction between the sexes, “you can’t highlight the beauty of each role.” And you can’t ask what it means “to be perfected” in either maleness or femaleness, or how best to “integrate” our strengths. After all, she adds, “to recognize distinctions is to recognize great things.”

As for how a renewal of feminine and masculine ideals would look like in modern society, Dr. Foley explains that the answer does not lie in a return to chivalry. It is not that the chivalric code is in tension with modern sensibilities, but that “it was already in tension” with Christianity because of its insistence on the particularity of certain virtues, casting them as gender-specific.

For instance, in “the code of chivalry, courage for a male was supremely important,” while “chastity for a female was supremely important.” Hence, says Dr. Foley, “that’s actually not an ethical code,” but it is rather “an honor code.” He adds: “According to Christian moral theology, all the virtues are equally important.” Thus, “a man is equally called to be” as “chaste as a woman,” and “a woman is equally called to be” as “courageous as a man.”

“The honor code,” Dr. Foley elucidates, “which is in our DNA from the very beginning, does indeed have a double-standard. We want men to be courageous and women to be chaste. Chivalry was a Christian truce between these two competing worldviews, and I say ‘truce’ because it did its best, but it wasn’t a fully integrated solution. I would like to see a code of chivalry brought back, but it can’t be brought back in a … brutish way, or in the same key that it was.”

“a man is equally called to be” as “chaste as a woman,” and “a woman is equally called to be” as “courageous as a man.”

Dr. Michael Foley

Dr. Foley’s point on the universality of Christian virtue is perhaps best illustrated by St. Joan of Arc. Mrs. Foley agrees and says that St. Joan is “such a wonderful example for us nowadays because she was perfectly feminine,” graceful and modest, “and yet God gave her this role” which involved both chastity and courage.

Indeed, Christianity has much to offer in terms of societal renewal, especially on the question of male and female identities.

In contrast with pre-Christian thought and culture, it rejects double-standards; and likewise, contrary to post-Christian thought and culture, it rejects the notion of there being no distinctions between the sexes, and is worrisome of the reduction of men and women to mere individuals with no necessity of relating to one another—i.e., the view that is probably best incapsulated by the famous, or rather infamous, feminist slogan: “a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle.”

Moreover, Catholic theology and doctrine in particular may be helpful guides in the pursuit of feminine and masculine ideals. “One of the great things about Catholic theology,” says Dr. Foley, “is that it understands the principles—the first principles, the important things—but it also understands the role that prudence plays in all of this; in adjudicating a myriad of circumstances.”

In the words of Mrs. Foley, the Church’s approach to questions of roles is one of “prudence informed by charity.” She explains that “in charity you see the other as the child of God, always thinking of that person in light of God—the light that shines upon your understanding of each other—and then you prudentially make decisions.”

Therefore, in terms of general principles, the Foleys “land on three different truths”:

  1. “That God created male and female, and it is good. The maleness and femaleness of the homosapiens is good.”
  2. “That does imply that there’s certain roles that male and female should assume.”
  3. “Those roles are” flexible or “up for grabs, given political circumstances and individual circumstances.”

The third principle may seem surprising to those who would have expected a prescription of specific “to-do’s.” But “there are no two marriages that are alike,” says Dr. Foley. “I, personally, am very skeptical about drawing up a laundry list for roles that the husband should play and the wife should play.” He adds: “I affirm the binary of male and female,” but acknowledging distinctions is not the same as “drawing up a nice, tidy list about what that means.”

In charity you see the other as the child of God, always thinking of that person in light of God—the light that shines upon your understanding of each other—and then you prudentially make decisions.”

Alexandra Foley

Of course, there are non-negotiables, as Mrs. Foley points out. “Birthing children,” she says, is obviously a uniquely female role, while “the male is the protector.” Dr. Foley agrees: “In a generic way, I would say that the male is in a sense the protector of the sacred,” while “the woman is an incarnation of the sacred.” But these roles can take a variety of forms, depending on “different circumstances, and this is where the virtue of prudence” is crucial.

This, once again, is another way in which Catholic tradition can help illustrate the healthy binary of male and female. “The sacred is consecrated,” says Dr. Foley, “set apart, and you see this in the liturgy: the males are in the sanctuary, protecting the sacred,” while “the woman is in many respects a profound symbol of the sacred, and we get this from the Blessed Virgin Mary. She is the new Ark of the Covenant, she is this keeper of the sacred, but she needs to be protected by St. Joseph.”

Icon of our Lady of Perpetual Help https://www.monasteryicons.com/product/Story-of-the-Most-Famous-Icon-of-the-Virgin-Mary/did-you-know

The Holy Family exemplifies this because Mary “literally embodies the sacred by having the Word of God in her womb, and St. Joseph needs to protect that at all costs.” Thus, Dr. Foley says: “I treat that as a basic starting point—the woman is sacred and the man is there to protect her, so he is at the service of his wife.”

Mrs. Foley embraces this paradigm and says that “it works both theologically” and “naturally.” The Holy Family, therefore, can serve as our highest ideal, and we can strive to prudentially emulate the spirit of what each member’s role embodies.

The sacred is consecrated, set apart, and you see this in the liturgy: the males are in the sanctuary, protecting the sacred, while the woman is in many respects a profound symbol of the sacred, and we get this from the Blessed Virgin Mary.

Dr. Micheal Foley

“When a woman is pregnant,” Mrs. Foley observes, “she’s vulnerable and she needs protection, and that’s an important role of the man.” But child-bearing and protection do not necessarily constrain an individual couple to gender-specific duties in and out of the household. The man, for example, may be the protector and the one who cooks most meals.

It may still be difficult for some women to consider these ideals without the suspicion that, at their core, they are merely masquerading the same restrictiveness of ages past. But perhaps this cynicism is due to a scarcity of feminine “icons,” i.e., women who perfectly embody virtue and are not “oppressed” by it, but rather empowered.

Once again, we may think of the Blessed Virgin Mary. As a Catholic woman, Mrs. Foley speaks of being ever inspired by “Mary as someone who is so important and so valuable.” She describes her as someone who “is valued for her relational quality,” as seen in “the way she relates to Jesus, St. Joseph, and then St. John.”

But the Blessed Virgin’s most important role, explains Mrs. Foley, is that of being at “the center of the Trinity: she is the daughter of God” the Father, “she is the spouse of the Holy Spirit, and she is the Mother of Christ. How can the role of the woman not be important?” It is in this way that “Mary’s role in my life has been so helpful.” Her intrinsically relational nature gives women “a sense of value.”

Likewise, for men, the Faith provides countless examples of virtuous masculinity, the first of which is, of course, “the everlasting man,” Christ Himself. But renewal need not be limited to those who subscribe to Christian orthodoxy. It begins by acknowledging differences, avoiding double-standards, and—in the words of Dr. Foley—prudentially embracing a healthy and wonderful “complementarity of the sexes.”

ShareTweetSend
Mike Ortiz

Mike Ortiz

Get The Standard in Your Inbox

Top Articles

  • Wasted or Worth It? Alumni Views on Baylor’s Liberal Arts

    Wasted or Worth It? Alumni Views on Baylor’s Liberal Arts

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Baylor Alumnus Gives Firsthand Account of Artemis II Capsule Recovery

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Science of Memes: How One Professor Studies Digital Culture

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • “All Are Neighbors” Event Platforms LGBTQ+ Advocates who say Inclusion is Faith-Motivated

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Honors Thesis that Became a Muse-ical

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
The Standard

© 2020 The Standard Speaks

Site Navigation

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Login

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Domestic
    • International
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Religion
  • Arts & Culture
  • Crossroads
  • About
    • Introducing The Standard

© 2020 The Standard Speaks