Donald Trump is a masculine icon. Conservative men venerate him for his frank speech and his business-savvy politics. In the 2024 presidential race, podcast appearances and “alpha male” language seemingly cemented Trump’s influence over young men.
It appears that Trump made men more conservative. But the facts show otherwise.

According to Gallup polling, the percentage of young conservative men has held relatively stable. Meanwhile, the percentage of young liberal women has jumped in the last decade.
This gender gap suggests that Trump has not persuaded more men to be conservative. Rather, he emboldened existing radical men and alienated previously moderate and conservative women.
How did Trump widen this political chasm between the sexes? And how can true conservativism win back radicals of both sexes?
The political divide between the sexes began well before Trump’s first presidency. Until 2013, Gallup polling shows that the political gender gap was relatively narrow. After 2013, a considerable number of conservative and moderate women shifted to the left, more than doubling the previous separation.
While Trump himself did not cause the political gender gap, he is emblematic of its underlying cause: a perversion of true conservative masculinity. Trump’s presidency spread this perversion publicly, further widening the political divide between the sexes.
Trump has not persuaded more men to be conservative. Rather, he emboldened existing radical men and alienated previously moderate and conservative women.
Contrary to conservatism’s emphasis on personal moral duty and accountability, Trump’s words and deeds reflect disregard for personal morality.
For example, Trump’s marital history is rife with infidelity and lack of commitment. Ivana Zelnickova, his first wife, divorced Trump after discovering his affair with Marla Maples, the woman who would become his second wife. Amid his divorce to Maples, Trump began dating Melania Knauss, his third and current wife. Trump is the only U.S. president with this kind of marital history.
In 2023, a jury awarded E. Jean Carroll millions of dollars in relation to Trump sexually assaulting her and defaming her. In 2024, a jury convicted Trump in connection with hush money payments made to a porn star who claimed to have sex with him. Both cases concern sexual encounters Trump allegedly had while he was married.

Trump infamously boasted that his celebrity status allowed him to kiss women and grab their genitals. “When you’re a star, they let you do it. You can do anything,” Trump said in the 2016 “Access Hollywood” recording. When the recording leaked, Trump gave a half-hearted apology and defended his comments as “locker room banter.”
Despite Trump’s known habits of promiscuity and lewdness, he and his allies are all too willing to dismiss legal attempts at accountability as political “lawfare.”
Many women reject conservatism because of this Trumpian behavior masquerading as conservative. They believe that conservatism fails to hold men accountable for their actions. Viral movements such as #metoo and #churchtoo seemed to expose the inadequacy of traditional institutions. Thus, many women seek liberal alternatives to counter male capriciousness and elevate female autonomy.
Conservatives should be the first to recognize Trump’s sexual practices as unconservative.
But if Trumpian masculinity isn’t conservative masculinity, then what is? Can true conservativism be a real solution to the political gender gap?
True conservative masculinity must be distinguished from the frauds. Barry Goldwater defines conservatism in The Conscience of a Conservative as “look[ing] upon politics as the art of achieving the maximum amount of freedom for individuals that is consistent with the maintenance of social order.”
Conservatives emphasize individuals’ responsibility for their own improvement and the dangers of concentrated political power. Conservatives also generally recognize humans as spiritual and ensouled beings, a quality which imbues each person, no matter their gender, with inviolable worth and dignity.
Following these principles, conservative masculinity respects others’ freedoms and responsibilities. True conservative men recognize that the concentration of power requires self-restraint and accountability, especially if that power lies in their own hands. Ultimately, conservative masculinity submits personal autonomy to moral duty.
To win back liberal converts, conservative men and women must actively combat abuses of power, especially if they occur within structures conservatives seek to promote. Conservatives should be the first to call out misogynistic patriarchy as tyranny. Conservatives should be the first to demand consequences for sexual abusers who infiltrate institutions, such as the church. Conservatives should be the first to recognize Trump’s sexual practices as unconservative.
If modern conservatives were as enthusiastic about punishing sexual violence as they were about punishing illegal immigration, the political gender gap could look drastically different.
Men have become so hardened by their fight against liberalism that they risk losing their sensitivity to true conservative values.
Conservatives must demand consistently moral leaders. Trump’s crackdown on transgender athletes and gender ideology correctly upholds the distinction between the sexes. However, protecting women-only spaces reads as hypocritical for someone found liable for sexually assaulting someone in a women’s dressing room.
Additionally, conservatives must win back men who have gone too far in the name of “conservatism.” Such men have become so hardened by their fight against liberalism that they risk losing their sensitivity to true conservative values.
For example, when 67 people died in a collision between a military helicopter and a commercial airliner this January, Trump blamed the incident on DEI policies and the gender of the pilot. Online outrage was quick to focus on the female helicopter pilot, regardless of her merit. Trump’s reversal of DEI policies is only a victory for meritocracy if it does not embolden discrimination and hatred.
Reining in “red pill” culture and the “manosphere” means catechizing young men in conservative values. Respect for all persons, accountable leadership, and moral responsibility are central to conservative masculinity.
In the end, winning back both liberal converts and radicalized men requires compassion. Ideological splintering hints at the immense suffering experienced by men and women alike. In such a hurting world, let us bridge the political gender gap by seeing beyond ideological caricatures and caring for humanity’s deepest needs.
Cover Photo from Christianity Today

